1. Benedict Cumberbatch
1. Benedict Cumberbatch 本尼迪克特·康伯巴奇
If Holmes is not cold,
inhumanly calculating and with an
addictive personality, he's just not Holmes. Cumberbatch's Sherlock in the BBC's updated
adaptation is all three. A Sherlock Holmes for the 21st century.
假如福爾摩斯不冷酷,不會還無人情味地推理,也沒有吸引人的個性,那他就不是福爾摩斯了。在BBC電視臺最新版本的《神探夏洛克》中,康伯巴奇扮演的福爾摩斯就是個集合了冷酷又會推理,性格又特殊而迷人。他是21世紀的福爾摩斯。
2. Basil Rathbone
2. Basil Rathbone 巴斯爾·拉斯伯恩
Basil Rathbone appeared in 14 Hollywood films made across 1939-1946 as Sherlock Holmes, and for all the time that has passed he remains many people's
quintessential Holmes. A charming, humane even gentlemanly Holmes, he certainly wouldn't have approved of Cumberbatch's
incarnation tossing that poor CIA agent out the window.
巴斯爾·拉斯伯恩參演了1939-1946年間的14部好萊塢電影,扮演的角色都是福爾摩斯,而他的福爾摩斯是人們心目中典型的福爾摩斯。他扮演的是一個迷人的、有人情的甚至風度翩翩的福爾摩斯,但也比不上康伯巴奇那活生生的、把中情局折騰夠的福爾摩斯形象。
3. Jeremy Brett
3. Jeremy Brett 杰里米·布雷特
For many, Jeremy Brett is Sherlock. His role in the Granada TV series The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes spanned 1984-94 and 42 productions.
說真的,杰里米·布雷特就是夏洛克。格拉納達電視臺在1984年-1994年斥資攝制了《福爾摩斯探案全集》,并有42個國家的版本。
4. Robert Downey Jr.
4. Robert Downey Jr. 小羅伯特·唐尼
Robert Downey Jr. was perhaps not the mostly likely Sherlock, but then there's not much
conventional about Guy Ritchie's
brawling, all-action take on Conan Doyle's creation. Pictured here in the 2009 Hollywood hit film Sherlock Holmes, Downey Jr.
portrays the brilliant detective as a
mischievous Victorian 007 but, amazingly, it works.
或許小羅伯特·唐尼不是最像福爾摩斯的一位,然而,蓋·里奇執(zhí)導的那吵吵鬧鬧的、全武行的電影與柯南·道爾的原創(chuàng)肯定不是在同一條道上的。在2009年上映的好萊塢熱播電影《大偵探福爾摩斯》中,小羅伯特·唐尼扮演了一個淘氣、才華橫溢的、生活在維多利亞時代的007,但令人驚訝的是,觀眾們的確買小羅伯特·唐尼的帳。
5. Robert Stephens
5. Robert Stephens 羅伯特·斯蒂芬斯
The great English actor made a brilliantly
unconventional Holmes in Billy Wilder's 1970 film The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes.
Ostensibly a
parody, the film is seen by some as an important influence on the new Sherlock.
斯提芬斯是一名偉大的英國演員,他在《福爾摩斯私生活》(比利·懷爾德在1970年攝制)中扮演了一名標新立異、讓人眼前一亮的福爾摩斯。這部電影表面看起來很粗糙,但是在一定程度上影響著后時代的福爾摩斯扮演者。
6. Arthur Wontner
6. Arthur Wontner 阿瑟·旺特納
Despite being not exactly physically suited to the part, the
rotund, round-faced actor got down to some
solidly authoritative clue solving in five British films during the 1930s.
圓頭圓臉的旺特納盡管在臉型上不適合福爾摩斯的扮演,但他在30年代的5部英國福爾摩斯電影中樹立起屬于自己的福爾摩斯形象。
7. John Barrymore
7. John Barrymore 約翰·巴里摩爾
The silent film star made for a
visually arresting Holmes in his one movie appearance as the detective in the film Sherlock Holmes in 1922.
這位默片明星在1922年的電影《夏洛克·福爾摩斯》中刻畫出一個俊俏的福爾摩斯。
8. Peter Cushing
8. Peter Cushing 彼得·庫欣
"Terror stalks the
moors! Horror fills the night!" This 1959
Hammer take on The
Hound of the
Baskervilles starring Peter Cushing - reunited with Christopher Lee who perhaps fares better as the supporting Watson - is a thrilling and stylish outing to Dartmoor.
“荒原布滿驚駭,夜晚充斥恐懼!”彼得·庫欣主演的、1959年哈默執(zhí)導的《巴斯克維爾的獵犬》(庫欣作為華生與克里斯托弗·李聯演時票房會更好)是一部去達特穆爾的流行、驚心動魄之旅。
9. Christopher Plummer
9. Christopher Plummer 克里斯托弗·普盧默
The British actor had two stabs at playing Holmes in Silver Blaze in 1977 and Murder by
Decree in 1979. Altogether too human and emotional to make the upper reaches of this list, it's nonetheless a thoroughly likeable portrayal.
這位英國演員在1977年的《銀火焰》和1979年的《午夜追殺》中扮演福爾摩斯。普盧默在人物的刻畫和情感的表達做得相當細膩,而兩部電影的票房也相當不錯。毫無疑問,他是一個討人喜愛的福爾摩斯。
10. Buster Keaton
10. Buster Keaton 巴斯特·基頓
Buster Keaton directed and starred in this wonderful 1924 silent film. Entitled Sherlock Jr. because its
protagonist is a young cinema
projectionist who dreams of becoming a famous detective like his idol, 29-year-old Keaton's child hero gets caught up in a movie-style mystery, complete with
hilarious runaway moped scene.
巴斯特·基頓導演并主演了1924年的默片《福爾摩斯二世》。在該片中,主角是一個年輕的電影放映師,夢想成為像福爾摩斯一樣的著名偵探。時年29歲的基頓用出色的電影技巧,將觀眾的情緒引入彀中而不自知。
11. Ian Richardson
11. Ian Richardson 伊安·理查德森
Long before Richardson made his name as the Machiavellian Francis Urquhart in House of Cards, he made a decent stab at playing Holmes in two mid-Eighties TV adaptations: The Hound of the Baskervilles and The Sign of Four.
在理查德森還沒扮演《失控的華爾街》中的狡猾的弗蘭西斯·厄克特之前,他已在兩部80年代中期的改編劇《巴斯克維爾的獵犬》和《四簽名》中扮演福爾摩斯,并嶄露頭角。
12. Rupert Everett
12. Rupert Everett 魯伯特·埃弗雷特
Rupert Everett played a
snooty,
dandyish Holmes with a taste for cutting put-downs in the 2004 BBC film Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Silk Stocking. For all that current Sherlock duo Cumberbatch and Freeman deny the Holmes-Watson chemistry goes beyond professional respect, Everett was in no doubt that theirs is "a love affair,
albeit one that is not really expressible".
在2004年BBC電影《福爾摩斯之絲纏奇案》中,魯伯特·埃弗雷特扮演的是一個傲慢的、花花公子般的,但又令人難以吐槽的福爾摩斯。當時的流行的說法是:夏洛克二人組——肯伯巴其和弗里曼否認福爾摩斯和華生之間超越了專業(yè)上的尊重,而埃弗雷特則無保留 地認為福爾摩斯和華生是“相愛卻不將愛意傳達的一對伴侶?!?/div>
13. Peter Cook
13. Peter Cook 彼得·庫克
Peter Cook and Dudley Moore paired up to spoof the The Hound of the Baskervilles in this 1978 comedy film, but for all the hamming-up an ensemble cast including Roy Kinnear, Kenneth Williams and Prunella Scales could muster, it was sadly short on laughs.
彼得·庫克和達德利·摩爾配合,在1978年把《巴斯克維爾的獵犬》愚弄了一番,并將其改成喜劇電影。盡管該部電影還聚集了羅伊·金尼爾、肯尼斯·威廉姆斯和普路利亞·斯卡斯這些影星,但是這部電影的笑點不多。
14. Christopher Lee
14. Christopher Lee 克里斯托弗·李
Horror star Lee had a chance to observe other actors playing Holmes close up, when he appeared as Sir Henry in the 1959 adaptation of The Hound of the Baskervilles, and later as Mycroft Holmes in The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes. His own three attempts at the role fell victim to a familiar trait of American actors in the part, a bit too
stiff, a bit too formal, rather lifeless.
拍驚栗片出身的的李常有機會近距離觀察其它福爾摩斯的扮演者,而此時的他在1959 年的《巴斯克維爾的獵犬》改編劇中擔任亨利爵士一角,不久后也接下了《福爾摩斯私生活》中邁克羅夫特·福爾摩斯的一角。三次的角色嘗試,讓李從一個失敗者成為一個美國家喻戶曉的特色影星,他扮演的角色有點太僵硬、又有點太正式,表現毫無生氣可言。
15. Tom Baker
15. Tom Baker 湯姆·貝克
Soon after leaving Doctor Who, Tom Baker took on Holmes in the 1983 BBC four-part serial The Hound of the Baskervilles. He may have been better off staying in the Tardis though, as he gave an oddly flat performance in this rather more traditional take on Holmes's most famous adventure than that seen on BBC One last night.
拍完《神秘博士》電視劇不久,湯姆·貝克接下了1983年BBC四集系列《巴斯克維爾的獵犬》中福爾摩斯一角。在《神秘博士》中,湯姆·貝克表演出色,而在《福爾摩斯探案集》,他表現平平,還有點奇怪,他的表演比我們昨天晚上在看《福爾摩斯》更文藝
。